(A Reader's Companion to the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings) [PDF NEW] ¼ Isaac Asimov

  • Paperback
  • 118
  • A Reader's Companion to the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings
  • Isaac Asimov
  • English
  • 24 September 2018
  • null

Isaac Asimov Æ 2 Free download

A Reader's Companion to the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings Read ☆ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free From the back coverThis books includes nearly four decades' worth of intelligent lively and controversial Tolkien commentary from some of the major literary figures of our time Here you will find W H Auden praising The Hobbit as one of the best children's. I don t think this book is well named as a Reader s Companion it fails at least in terms of what I m usually looking for in books with that sort of title While I would recommend this to Tolkien fans I do not recommend it to someone who isn t familiar with the books or who is looking for considered analysis or discussion Many of the articles here were originally reviews in some periodical like the New York Times and most of them were written by people who ve read the books only once As such some of them make some pretty laughable errors like the plot summary from The Times Literary Supplement which says that when the Ring had an impact on Bilbo s health and the evil magician sent spies into the Shire to win it from him Bilbo consulted the White Council of Elves and magicians who led the powers of Good As a result his nephew Frodo Baggins was deputed to carry the Ring to the evil realm of MordorWrong in so many ways Plus a lot of the articles are on the phenomenon of LOTR as much about the books popularity as about the books There s also an article that gives some tidbits on Tolkien and LeGuin s is about how the books impacted her personally but those are the two big exceptions OTOH as a fan I liked the fact that it has a lot of the essays you ll see regularly uoted in other books on Tolkien for instance the notorious Edmund Wilson essay as well as CS Lewis original reviews Wilson argues that Frodo has no serious temptations is lured by no insidious enchantments perplexed by few problems and that James Branch Cabell s Poictesme is far superior Even without knowing anything about Cabell it s clear that Wilson s review boils down to Tolkien should have written a totally different book which is an approach I rarely have patience with I will occasionally come to the conclusion that this book is not for me but I figure if someone is going to go to the trouble of writing a book they get to write the kind of book they want Still Wilson pretty clearly exposes the mindset of many who hate the books which is useful I thought All the articles including Wilson s are uite readable and it s entertaining to see what people are looking for or find in the books on in many cases their first read The only article I had read before was Ursula K LeGuin s which may or may not be in her Language of the Night collection can t remember even though I read it once a year for probably a decade but at any rate it s an old favorite of mine I think she s uite right when she says reading Tolkien when young could be bad for someone who is fated to grow up and write fantasy novels I read some of Tolkien s imitators and I don t think they had any impact on my own writing at all but reading LOTR in my teens would have been something else entirely While I argue with the title this is a nice collection of essays and two of the last three articles are well chosen After so many articles written by people who don t get the books or the phenomenon and are talking from outside it s lovely to read the Philip Norman article that uotes Tolkien directly and clears up some earlier misuotes and then LeGuin s article is a nice taste of what the fans are getting out of it Despite the fact that they sandwich the laughably inaccurate but generally positive Times Literary Supplement article they re a surprisingly satisfying ending to an entertaining if lightweight collection

Summary A Reader's Companion to the Hobbit and the Lord of the RingsA Reader's Companion to the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings

A Reader's Companion to the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings Read ☆ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free T only a colorful survey of American and British literary and cultural tastes over several generations but a multifaceted tribute to one man and his imagination that is sure to enhance and deepen a reader's understanding of Tolkien's two most famous works. My edition is published by uality Paperback Book Club A Reader s Companion is a collection of responses to both The Hobbit and TLOR when the books first were published It includes essays by C S Lewis Issac Asimov Ursula K Le Guin and W H Auden Some essays are favorable to the books while others are not

Read ✓ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Æ Isaac Asimov

A Reader's Companion to the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings Read ☆ PDF, DOC, TXT, eBook or Kindle ePUB free Stories of this century; Edmund Wilson deriding The Lord of the Rings as an overgrown fairy story; and critues by C S Lewis in the 1950s Ursula K Le Guin in the 70s and Isaac Asimov in the 80s What emerges from these twelve provocative commentaries is no. Nice book compiling some magazine articles on the Tolkien books from around when they came out including several written by luminaries CS Lewis Isaac Asimov Ursula K LeGuin I mostly read this because it was a very short book I had hanging around that I hadn t read and we re trying to get rid of most of our books before moving It was definitely nice to be back in the world of Middle Earth for a while even at one remove And although the writers have different perspectives I found myself agreeing with each of them while I was reading them Developing a Winner's Heart (Music CD) (Upward Music CD to Compliment "Winner Magazine" and Learn "Scripture Verse" for Practice Each Week) no. Nice book compiling some magazine articles on the Tolkien books from around when they came out including several written by luminaries CS Lewis Isaac Asimov Ursula K LeGuin I mostly read this because it was a very short book I had hanging around that I hadn t read and we re trying to get rid of most of our books before moving It was definitely Gli uomini vengono da Marte le donne da Venere: Il libro sui rapporti di coppia più venduto nel mondo nice to be back in the world of Middle Earth for a while even at one remove And although the writers have different perspectives I found myself agreeing with each of them while I was reading them